Outside of a Dog

Ben Harris-Roxas started reading Matter by Iain M. Banks

Matter by Iain M. Banks

In a world renowned even within a galaxy full of wonders, a crime within a war. For one brother it …

Ben Harris-Roxas replied to Dr Ms Kat's status

@pelagikat It’s v good imho

Ben Harris-Roxas replied to sneedy maccreedy's status

@crumbleneedy@aus.social @ben_hr@old.mermaid.town They were amongst my most-loved books as a young adult (in the not-a-teenager sense, not the current book marketing one) but they're much more flawed that I recalled. I think my tastes are now more literary, but I've also read a lot of dumb shit over the years so I may also be less tolerant? 🤷🏽‍♂️

Ben Harris-Roxas reviewed Look to Windward by Iain M. Banks

Look to Windward (Paperback, 2001, Orbit)

It was one of the less glorious incidents of a long-ago war.

It led to …

Huge themes, muddled

4 stars

This should clearly be understood as a companion to Consider Phlebas. That book devotes so much time to world-building, it doesn’t fully explore the characters’ motivations. In contrast Look to Windward is all about the characters.

It’s a novel about regret, trauma, and revenge, and it does it well. I didn’t care for the revelations at the end of the book. It’s a crutch that Banks relies on in almost all Culture novels – the Minds knew all and manipulated everyone all along! That’s not quite what was going on here, but it is in part.

Banks’ concern for the impact of war on those who fight it is clear. This is a compassionate book. This coda was hidden and only revealed at the end, which, to me, is a sign of an author who doesn’t fully trust or respect their readers. We need “the prestige”, to borrow that magician’s …

This should clearly be understood as a companion to Consider Phlebas. That book devotes so much time to world-building, it doesn’t fully explore the characters’ motivations. In contrast Look to Windward is all about the characters.

It’s a novel about regret, trauma, and revenge, and it does it well. I didn’t care for the revelations at the end of the book. It’s a crutch that Banks relies on in almost all Culture novels – the Minds knew all and manipulated everyone all along! That’s not quite what was going on here, but it is in part.

Banks’ concern for the impact of war on those who fight it is clear. This is a compassionate book. This coda was hidden and only revealed at the end, which, to me, is a sign of an author who doesn’t fully trust or respect their readers. We need “the prestige”, to borrow that magician’s phrase.

This project of re-reading the Culture novels has been interesting. It makes me realise that Banks was a good writer but not a great one. I wonder how long his works will endure and be read.

Ben Harris-Roxas finished reading Look to Windward by Iain M. Banks

Look to Windward by Iain M. Banks

It was one of the less glorious incidents of a long-ago war.

It led to the destruction of two suns …

Ben Harris-Roxas replied to Dr Ms Kat's status

@pelagikat Please report

Ben Harris-Roxas replied to Emily Gorcenski's status

@EmilyG@bookwyrm.social Enjoying it? I know some find it slow or alienating.

Ben Harris-Roxas reviewed Excession by Iain M. Banks

Two and a half millennia ago, the artifact appeared in a remote corner of space, …

Surprisingly thin

3 stars

Rereading books is an interesting exercise. Books are unchanging. They remind us of their original qualities; what drew us to them. They can never change with us.

Excession is the first Culture novel where Banks gives us much insight into the Minds and the Culture itself. I remember loving this book in the ‘90s, it felt so fresh and original.

Now it seems more like a shaggy dog story. It never gets to the point, if there is a point, and the characters are single-note vehicles for plot alone. I was really disappointed.