Reviews and Comments

Barbarius Locked account

Barbarius@outside.ofa.dog

Joined 2 years, 2 months ago

Mostly reading sci-fi, fantasy, and comics/graphic novels, but occasionally some other stuff too.

This link opens in a pop-up window

Alex Pavesi: Eight Detectives (Paperback, 2020, Penguin Books, Limited)

All murder mysteries follow a simple set of rules. Grant McAllister, a mystery writer and …

Very good, but I didn't love the ending.

This is a great murder mystery novel. The blurb basically says it all: a retired mathematician defined all the essential parameters of murder mystery novels, described the possible permutations, and then released a collection of seven short stories that demonstrated all the permutations. The story goes through the stories, and describes the permutations along the way.

The book is easy to read, as it's basically a collection of short stories, and it's a great read.

What I don't like about the blurb is that it implies that there's a greater mystery to solve. I don't like this implication, because it's not possible for the reader to solve this greater mystery, because they aren't given all the facts until the revelation at the conclusion. The conclusion is still excellent; it's a lovely part of the story and a good ending, but it's not a mystery you can solve.

reviewed You Look Like Death by Gerard Way (Tales from the Umbrella Academy, #1)

Gerard Way, Nate Piekos, Shaun Simon, I.N.J. Culbard: You Look Like Death (Paperback, 2021, Dark Horse Books)

Scratches the UA comics itch

You Look Like Death was a good, but not great story.

It's a six-issue story following Klaus/Séance after he gets kicked out of home by Hargreeves. He goes on a drug bender, talks with dead people, and has somewhat of a redemption arc where he helps people.

It's nice. It was great to get a story fleshing out the comic book world that has somewhat been overshadowed by the TV series in recent years. But it's not as strong as the main stories published so far.

But, still worth reading if you've read the other three already 👍

reviewed Mona Lisa Overdrive by William Gibson (The Neuromancer Trilogy, #3)

William Gibson: Mona Lisa Overdrive (Paperback, 2017, GOLLANCZ)

Mona Lisa Overdrive is the final novel of the William Gibson's cyberpunk Sprawl trilogy.

A good conclusion

Content warning Character revelation from previous book, and how the final chapter content relates to the first book that's not too specific.

reviewed Superman Action Comics - Vol. 2 by Dan Jurgens (Action Comics 2016, #963-966)

Dan Jurgens, Tom Grummett, Patrick Zircher, Stephen Segovia, Art Thibert: Superman Action Comics - Vol. 2 (GraphicNovel, 2017, DC Comics)

Look! Down there on the ground! It's...Clark Kent?! As Metropolis recovers from the devastating attack …

Too many parts and not enough resolution.

Admittedly, I've only read this one TPB, but it's story is not well contained at all.

One thing I really don't like in comic series is when there are so many publications all at once that you can't get a coherent storyline unless you read all of them. This is an example of that problem.

I know this is early in the "Rebirth" reboot, but it still means that I've read 128 pages for basically not much of anything...