Reviews and Comments

Phil Locked account

gleamy.wad@outside.ofa.dog

Joined 12 months ago

I study authoritarians and enjoy poetry. Reading all those books in Cyrillic. he/him

This link opens in a pop-up window

Зимняя дорога (Hardcover, Russian language, 2015, АСТ) 3 stars

Леонид Юзефович — известный писатель, историк, автор романов "Казароза", "Журавли и карлики" и др., биографии …

Авторские допущения и жменька пассионарности

3 stars

Юзефович никогда не даёт забыть, что это в первую очередь роман: даже мемуарной основы не хватит, чтобы предполагать то, что он предполагает о чувствах и намерениях героев. Чмошная цитата Метерлинка в конце — логичный вывод из авторской позиции последних четырёх-пяти глав.

Очерки преступного мира (EBook, Russian language, 2014, Агентство ФТМ) 5 stars

Варлама Шаламова справедливо называют большим художником, автором глубокой психологической и философской прозы. Написанное Шаламовым — …

Самый категоричный сборник в цикле

5 stars

Метод Шаламова будто бы истончается в форме эссе, но это только разнообразит критику воровской «морали»

Equal Rites (2005) 4 stars

Equal Rites is a comic fantasy novel by Terry Pratchett. Published in 1987, it is …

A fine book about ecology

4 stars

I think it’s on the opposite side of the spectrum from Clarke’s “Piranesi” — and I like Pratchett’s viewpoint more: Clarke’s magic is desired and unreachable for those who seek it, so it’s a character of its own; Pratchett’s Esk postulates that not using magic when it’s there in your hands can be more important than using it, and that’s goes further than just admitting of its agency, it adds a very important nuance: whose agency is more of the liability to the living.

More literally Pratchett’s ecology is delivered in passages about Borrowing and things’ names and minds (Granny’s goats, and rocks of the University), but magic is the ultimate example of goals and means being one thing.

Мондеґрін. Пісні про смерть і любов (Ukrainian language, 2019) No rating

Good at actualizing modalities of its region, but laden with male gaze

No rating

Most interesting takes on national literature always come from outsiders—like Kulbak’s “Raysn,” both silly and convincing, or Gogol’s “Mirgorod.”

Rafeyenko also has that complex background which lets him synthesise different worlds. Not he’s only a writer with seven Russian-language novels, but also a literary critic. In 2014 he was displaced from Donetsk to Kyiv (I have little understanding what chunk of life he had lost then, and it’s a bad habit to draw conclusions from person’s literary alter egos). A year ago, I’ve read his second-to-last book, “Length of Days,” about the presence of the war in Donetsk and Kyiv, about “national unity” that struggles to be born.

It’s pretty common to see national myths using women as substitute for Homeland, giving them roles to play in the national order: of a mother, of a lover, so one may seek her valorously, or loose her tragically. Rafeyenko too uses such …

Черный ветер, белый снег (Hardcover, Russian language, 2017, Фантом Пресс) 1 star

Чарльз Кловер много лет работал шефом московского бюро Financial Times. В своей книге он прослеживает …

I wasn’t as angry as I was exhausted by all this.

1 star

Charles Clover’s Black Wind, White Snow is of course a good example how liberals are in owe of fascisms, but hey, it’s also poor researched!

Clover says he interviewed a lot of Nazbols, it seems like they instilled their ideas of Russian history in him (deterministic and stripped of reasoning). It overlaps with him trying to fit rich Amerikkan political lore over Russia, regardless of the era: “deep state”, “culture wars”, and “orthodox Marxism” (meaning some unified Soviet ideology) are regularly mentioned.

Book promises to explain phenomenon of “Russkiy mir” through the stories of political activism of Russian émigrés, Liev Gumilyov (one “spontaneous anarchist”!), and Alexandr Dugin. They all happen to be vewy cuwious chawactews, vewy talented, but twoubled intewectchuals, who fall for bigotwy and antisemitism by mewe accident. Also, they are all like Dostoyevsky in one way or another (it’s hard to portray Nikita Tikhonov as Dostoevsky, but Clover …