Profoundly disappointing and directionless. The characterisation is thin, the plot moves but seemingly erratically, and overall it’s bereft of ideas. This is the first in a series—I won’t be continuing.
Reviews and Comments
Researcher and educator from Sydney, Australia. You’ll usually find me on the forgotten parts of the web.
My ratings ★ Not recommended ★★ Not for me, but may be okay for you? ★★★ Good ★★★★ Very good, recommended ★★★★★ Exceptional, couldn't put it down
This link opens in a pop-up window
Ben Harris-Roxas reviewed Noumenon by Marina J. Lostetter
Ben Harris-Roxas rated Collapse: 3 stars

Collapse by Vladislav M. Zubok
In 1945 the Soviet Union controlled half of Europe and was a founding member of the United Nations. By 1991, …
Ben Harris-Roxas reviewed Ten Planets by Yuri Herrera
Bumpy
3 stars
Disappointingly uneven, though I appreciated the broader perspective that hadn’t been through the very narrow filter of the limited number of English language short fiction publishers.
Ben Harris-Roxas reviewed Creation Lake by Rachel Kushner
The best book I've read in years
5 stars
Creation Lake is a spy novel, ostensibly, but it's immediately more than that. It's an examination of French politics and class, the "spy cops" scandal, and the demise of Neanderthals.
The book follows Sadie, a corporate spy who's detached to the point of sociopathy. But her wry observations are compelling. She's amoral, brutal and unsentimental, but also smart and amusing. She draws you in though you know she cannot be trusted, even as a narrator.
Rachel Kushner seems unusual in the context of contemporary American literature for her ability to weave global sociopolitical observations into narratives that switch back and further between contemporary issues and historical events.
Kushner's prose is both concise and poetic where it needs to be. She shows real skill in capturing human experiences against historical timescales. What's particularly impressive about this book is Kushner's sharp handling of both time and space. She weaves …
Creation Lake is a spy novel, ostensibly, but it's immediately more than that. It's an examination of French politics and class, the "spy cops" scandal, and the demise of Neanderthals.
The book follows Sadie, a corporate spy who's detached to the point of sociopathy. But her wry observations are compelling. She's amoral, brutal and unsentimental, but also smart and amusing. She draws you in though you know she cannot be trusted, even as a narrator.
Rachel Kushner seems unusual in the context of contemporary American literature for her ability to weave global sociopolitical observations into narratives that switch back and further between contemporary issues and historical events.
Kushner's prose is both concise and poetic where it needs to be. She shows real skill in capturing human experiences against historical timescales. What's particularly impressive about this book is Kushner's sharp handling of both time and space. She weaves together the contemporary, the postwar and even the Neolithic in Creation Lake while addressing themes about capitalism, sexism and emic/etic perspectives.
Without getting too wanky about it, this is a deeply intertextual work that won't bore the piss out of you. It rewards reading without punishing you for the act.
The best book I've read in years. Kushner's got game. I haven't read any of her other work, but I'll definitely do so immediately.
Ben Harris-Roxas reviewed Beyond the Light Horizon by Ken MacLeod
Ben Harris-Roxas started reading Creation Lake by Rachel Kushner
Kushner is a hell of a writer. She's created one of the least likeable narrative POV characters ever, yet I feel compelled to read on. The attention to detail and her clear attention to structure and pacing are great.
Kushner is a hell of a writer. She's created one of the least likeable narrative POV characters ever, yet I feel compelled to read on. The attention to detail and her clear attention to structure and pacing are great.
Ben Harris-Roxas stopped reading The Uninhabitable Earth: Life After Warming by David Wallace-Wells
Ben Harris-Roxas started reading The Uninhabitable Earth: Life After Warming by David Wallace-Wells
Ben Harris-Roxas reviewed Y: The Last Man - Deluxe Edition, Book 1 by Brian K. Vaughan (Y: The Last Man #1-2)
Ben Harris-Roxas finished reading Y: The Last Man - Deluxe Edition, Book 1 by Brian K. Vaughan (Y: The Last Man #1-2)
I should have read this a long time ago. Probably one of the most sublime and groundbreaking comics I've read.
I should have read this a long time ago. Probably one of the most sublime and groundbreaking comics I've read.
Ben Harris-Roxas stopped reading The Long Earth by Terry Pratchett (The Long Earth, #1)
Ben Harris-Roxas reviewed Beyond the Reach of Earth by Ken MacLeod
Loose ends tied up
4 stars
Not as engaging or imaginative as the first, it mostly served to tie up plot points and intrigue. I've begun the third book but in many ways it seems unneeded? Perhaps McLeod will explore new ideas in it.
Not as engaging or imaginative as the first, it mostly served to tie up plot points and intrigue. I've begun the third book but in many ways it seems unneeded? Perhaps McLeod will explore new ideas in it.









