Reviews and Comments

73pctGeek

73pctGeek@bookwyrm.social

Joined 1 year, 11 months ago

73% geek, the rest is girly bits.

I'm a shy lurker who enjoys friendly interaction but is bad at initiating. I like reading. Find me elsewhere on my blog, on mastodon, on pixelfed.art (art), and pixelfed.social (other stuff).

What my stars mean: ★☆☆☆☆ Hated it ★★☆☆☆ Didn't like it ★★★☆☆ It was OK ★★★★☆ Liked it ★★★★★ Loved it

This link opens in a pop-up window

T. Kingfisher: Hemlock and Silver (2025, Pan Macmillan)

"From New York Times bestselling and Hugo Award-winning author T. Kingfisher comes Hemlock & Silver, …

Enjoyable twist to a fairytale

Anja drinks poison. A lot.

Healer Anja, the usual competent Kingfisher protagonist, is hired to uncover the mystery of how someone is being poisoned. Cats, bodyguards, some really creepy bits, and a satisfyingly true to life resolution of the final, niggling “plot hole” make this an enjoyable twist on a certain fairytale.

T. Kingfisher: Nettle & Bone (Hardcover, 2022, Tor Books)

Chickens, curses and comeuppance

Princess Marra needs to figure out how to rescue not only herself, but her siblings too.

Another enjoyable fantasy from T. Kingfisher. This one feels a little darker in tone than Kingfisher’s non-horror fare, and is very fairytalesque, with godmothers, and princesses, and kings. As usual, Marra the protagonist is satisfyingly down-to-earth, and works with the tools at her disposal to attain her goals. A nice, quick read about comeuppances and chickens.

Robert Caro: The Power Broker (Paperback, 1975)

One of the most acclaimed books of our time, winner of both the Pulitzer and …

Long, but worthwhile

A potted history of a city, and a multitude of mini biographies are all contained within a shockingly in-depth biography of a single man. A man who shaped one of the biggest cities in the world in large, literally concrete ways. This is an amazing work, and I cannot begin to understand how Caro managed to pull this all together into a cohesive, readable book.

It is long, at times tedious, often shocking, and always illuminating, but definitely most interesting if you have more than a passing familiarity with New York City. I have only visited once, and thus miss a lot of the subtleties of Moses’ machinations. Nevertheless, this was a rewarding book to read, and I wish it were possible for me to visit NYC again (not happening on this timeline), and pay attention to all the places mentioned.

Caro is an adept writer, at first …

William Somerset Maugham: The Painted Veil (2006)

The worst Maugham I've read

Kitty has an affair which leads to difficult consequences.

I didn’t care for this. Unlike “Of Human Bondage” in which Maugham mesmerised me with his prose, I found the dialogue stilted, flat and the writing tiresome. When I looked it up, I was stunned to learn “The Painted Veil” was written a decade after “Of Human Bondage”.

Kitty, the rather unpleasant protagonist, is a spoilt, shallow child of a woman who marries a man she barely even likes, on a whim. Her development throughout the novel didn’t ring true, and seemed unlikely, making her character feel flat and unbelievable. I just couldn’t manage to suspend my disbelief of the transformation she undergoes. I found the setting bland, didn’t care for any of the characters, didn’t enjoy the plot, and felt very disappointed by the ending. In short, not for me.

V.E. Schwab (duplicate): Bury Our Bones in the Midnight Soil

Santo Domingo de la Calzada, 1532. London, 1837. Boston, 2019.

Three young women, their …

Slight twists to classic lore

Alice, Charlotte and Maria all hunger for a life different than circumstance has afforded them.

An enjoyable read with a slightly different take on vampires. I love the title, and the twists to classic vampire lore Schwab plays with. Much of the book is historical fiction, and also queer, both of which I find appealing.

While I found the stories of Maria and Charlotte most engaging, Alice’s used a few tropes I am thoroughly tired of. Her chapters were the ones I least enjoyed. I also found the denouement somewhat lacking. Otherwise, a fun read with well-defined characters and interesting storylines.

Margaret Verble: Cherokee America (2019, Thorndike Press)

Spring, 1875, in the Cherokee Nation West. A baby, a black hired hand, a bay …

Good, but sprawling

Check, matriarch and soon-to-be-widow, attempts to keep friends and family safe while living in the Cherokee Nation in 1875.

A fine read, but a little too sprawling and unfocused for my tastes. I found Verble’s “Stealing” a much more intimate and compelling read. Partly because “Cherokee America” isn’t written in first person, but also because its wide-ranging portrayal of a time and place which touches upon many characters and situations lacks the sensitive depiction of a single protagonist I so appreciated in “Stealing”.

reviewed Anna Karenina by Leo Tolstoy (A Margellos world republic of letters book)

Leo Tolstoy: Anna Karenina (2014)

In nineteenth-century Russia, the wife of an important government official loses her family and social …

This is not a love story

Anna Karenina falls in love with Count Vronsky.

Considered one of the great novels, after reading ‘Anna Karenina’ I’m not sure why. This is my first Tolstoy and while I enjoyed a couple of Dostoyevsky novels ages ago, I’m unsure whether I simply don’t care for Tolstoy or have meanwhile soured on Russian classics in general.

Though the prose might be sublime in the original, I read the Maude translation and found it fair to middling. It was bloodless and dispassionate, with a lot of telling and little showing. Nothing really seems to happen or matter, even though there are deaths and births and scandals.

There are many characters with many names, and because no-one is particularly interesting, they tended to blend together. Once nicknames were added to the mix, I really struggled at times. Add in the excessive amounts of philosophising on religion, politics, peasantry, and …

reviewed The Thursday Murder Club by Richard Osman (The Thursday Murder Club, #1)

Richard Osman: The Thursday Murder Club (Paperback, 2020, Penguin Books, Limited)

Welcome to... THE THURSDAY MURDER CLUB

In a peaceful retirement village, four unlikely friends …

Not my kinda crime

A group of retirees get together every Thursday and solve cold cases, but one day a hot one in need of solving shows up.

I wanted to like this more than I actually did. While I understand why people enjoy these books, they just aren’t my kind of thing. I didn’t like the crimes, nor the resolutions, and had issues suspending my disbelief about how much detecting the Murder Club could actually do, and found it all a bit too sappy in the end.

Arkady Martine: Rose/House (EBook, Subterranean Press)

Basit Deniau’s houses were haunted to begin with.

A house embedded with an artificial …

Didn't enjoy as much as I'd hoped

Det. Maritza Smith needs to solve the mystery inside Rose House, but the only way she can get in is if Dr. Selene Gisil allows it.

While I very much enjoyed Martine’s Teixcalaan Series, and I found the idea behind Rose/House extremely appealing, I didn’t care for this at all. I found the characters bland, the prose slippery and overly descriptive, and the denouement ultimately unsatisfying. I’d much rather read another Teixcalaan novel.

John Green: Everything Is Tuberculosis (Hardcover, 2025, Penguin Young Readers Group)

Tuberculosis has been entwined with humanity for millennia. Once romanticized as a malady of poets, …

An interesting and important book

John Green weaves the story of Henry Reider into the tale of how tuberculosis has shaped and been shaped by history.

Green is a fine fiction writer, and the clear and factual way in which he makes his case in “Everything Is Tuberculosis” shows he has a deft hand with non-fiction too. Even when turning the emotional screws, he steers clear of sentimentality. It is an interesting read, though I learnt somewhat less than expected due to my pre-existing interest in tuberculosis.

Even presuming the numbers and facts laid before the reader are wildly exaggerated, I see no real argument against Green’s plea. In fact, I agree wholeheartedly with it. We should be doing all we can to cure tuberculosis.

I’ll even go a step further. I truly believe we should be doing all we can to cure disease and alleviate suffering where we can. Fuck cost-effectiveness. …

reviewed Brigands and Breadknives by Travis Baldree (Legends & Lattes, #2)

Travis Baldree: Brigands and Breadknives (Paperback, 2025, Tor)

Return to the cozy fantasy world of the #1 New York Times bestselling Legends & …

Extremely charming

Fern the rattkin is dissatisfied, and uproots her life, heading off to Thune to set up shop next to a certain coffee shop.

Absolutely adorable. A lovely, cosy read following Fern, who is possibly even more foul-mouthed in middle age. Delightful characters show up, some new and some old, and the story itself is very sweet, albeit rather more adventures than previous instalments in the series. I find Fern extremely charming, and I really hope she will return as a main character in future novels. Where is the Legends & Latte TTRPG? At least give us a lore book! Take my money!

Margaret Verble: Stealing (2023, HarperCollins Publishers)

Made me want to read more Verble

After Kit’s mother dies, her need for connection leads her to make friends with Bella, a young newcomer in town.

The writing is excellent, and Kit is written with great tenderness. She feels like a real little girl in a real world. As her story meanders back and forth, the blanks get filled in, and the reader gets sucker punched more than once. I’ll be reading more Verble.

Jeff VanderMeer: Annihilation (2015)

Absolutely not for me

The twelfth expedition enters Area X.

This is not a bad book, Annihilation is just absolutely not for me. I didn't enjoy the premise, characters, world-building, story, all of it was dull verbiage. I cannot stand supernatural stuff, it reads like tedious bullshit to me. Which is, coincidently, how I'd describe this book. I got a strong “Lost” vibe from it, and if one considers that a good thing, I can see Annihilation being enjoyable.

Mary Roach: Replaceable You (2025)

The body is the most complex machine in the world, and the only one for …

Would like more depth

What bits of the human body are replaceable, and why is it so difficult?

I’ve read most of the popular science books Roach has written, and enjoyed them all. “Replaceable You” is no different, it’s an easy read about an interesting topic, and I learnt a lot. However, I didn’t find Roach’s writing as charming as before, and suspect it’s me rather than any fault of hers. I’d just like a lot more facts, and a bit less breezy chattiness.

Patric Gagne, Patric Gagne: Sociopath (Hardcover, english language, 2024, Simon & Schuster)

Patric Gagne realized she made others uncomfortable before she started kindergarten. Something about her caused …

Didn't think sociopathy could be this dull

Patric Gagne is a diagnosed sociopath.

I didn't care for this at all. Gagne makes reading about sociopathy a slog. It's tediously repetitive and feels like it was written by an aspiring novelist (uncomplimentary). Endless recreations of banal conversations, constant rumination on her sociopathy, usually self-congratulatory, and nowhere in the book does she evince any charm whatsoever. Learnt nothing, big waste of my time.