Reviews and Comments

73pctGeek

73pctGeek@bookwyrm.social

Joined 2 years, 7 months ago

73% geek, the rest is girly bits.

I'm a shy lurker who enjoys friendly interaction but is bad at initiating. I like reading. Find me elsewhere on my blog, or on mastodon.

What my stars mean: ★☆☆☆☆ Hated it ★★☆☆☆ Didn't like it ★★★☆☆ It was OK ★★★★☆ Liked it ★★★★★ Loved it

This link opens in a pop-up window

reviewed The Proof House by K.J. Parker (The Fencer Trilogy, #3)

K.J. Parker: The Proof House (Paperback, 2003, Orbit)

Not quite the conclusion I was hoping for

Bardas Loredan, ex fencer-at-law and former commander, puts his exceptional skills to work as a sapper, and suddenly finds himself a hero of the Empire and is thusly rewarded.

Some characters return, some fade away. A lot of battles. Some interesting bits on armour. Slightly bittersweet ending. Bardas continues to suffer at the pen of Parker. Must admit I liked this one less than the previous two, and I’d have liked a somewhat more definitive dénouement. Also realised I definitely prefer Parker’s protagonists when they are both the main character and a very shifty individual.

reviewed The Belly of the Bow by K.J. Parker (The Fencer Trilogy, #2)

K.J. Parker: The Belly of the Bow (2003, Warner Books)

Enjoyable second instalment

Bardas Loredan, no longer fencer-at-law, attempts to make a living as a bowyer. Unfortunately, both his relatives, the Bank, and the Foundation are about to thoroughly stymie him.

I didn’t find this quite as engaging as Colours in the Steel, the first in the Fencer trilogy, but it was still an enjoyable read. Though reacquainted with most of the characters, one or two are replaced by new ones, and we have left the city of Perimadeia far behind. The story is split, between various locations, and character viewpoints, often with jumps that can seem jarring, but serve to keep the reader on their toes.

The fencing scenes from book one have been replaced by warfare as both Scona and Shastel lack the trial by combat lawfare aspect that I found so intriguing. However, there are lots of lovely (and some less so) descriptions of the bowyer’s craft, which …

K.J. Parker: Sister Svangerd and the Devil You Know (EBook, Orbit US)

When the Church of the Invincible Sun is looking for someone to do its dirty …

Enjoyable, with some *really* good bits

When the Church of the Invincible Sun needs dirty deeds done Sister Svangerd heeds the call. This time all she needs to do is help her pet priest steal a book. Easy, right?

Second in the Loyal Opposition series, wherein Svangerd and her priest continue her adventures and his travails. Svangerd remains a delightful foil to her long-suffering and constant sidekick. The story is fine, but Parker writing about tech, forgery, creating convoluted personas, etc. is spectacular. I absolutely adore the bits where his protagonist digs in and explains how it all works. It’s utterly believable, and I never tire of it. I just wish there was more. Will happily read the final book.

Carl's Doomsday Scenario (Dungeon Crawler Carl) (Penguin publishing group)

The adventures continue

She is royalty, he is clad in underwear, together they’re taking on the Over City.

Carl and Donut’s escapades continue, now past the “training levels”, the real challenges lie before them. While I still find Donut charming, her catness seems to be waning, what with how caring she appears to be around virtual strangers. I’m still not personally convinced by the LitRPG genre, finding it slightly tedious at times.

reviewed Colours in the Steel by K.J. Parker (The Fencer Trilogy, #1)

K.J. Parker: Colours in the Steel (2003, Warner Books)

Enjoyable first book

Bardas Loredan, fencer-at-law, contemplates retirement completely unaware of the various forces conspiring against him, specifically. Personally, even.

Interesting book with overlapping viewpoints of various characters, some of which who are directly working against one another. Perimadeia, the city where most of the book takes place, has an absolutely fascinating system of law and lawyers.

Lacks the shifty narrator I’ve come to associate with Parker books, but I still found it a very enjoyable read. First in the series, and I’d definitely be finishing the Fencer trilogy.

reviewed The Queen of Nothing by Holly Black (The Folk Of The Air, #3)

Holly Black: The Queen of Nothing (Paperback, Hot Key Books)

Meh

High Queen of Faerie, yet exiled to the mortal realm, Jude is determined to reclaim what is hers.

I liked this even less than the previous one. The protagonist continues to be annoyingly overwrought, and her decisions continue to be tediously unsurprising. This wasn’t a particularly satisfying conclusion to the trilogy, nor was the “romance” in any way interesting or believable. Again, this book is not in any way written for someone like me and that is fine. I just think this genre probably has more captivating and compelling examples to offer.

Agatha Christie: Hickory dickory dock (1984, Fontana)

Normally, a mere outbreak of petty thefts in a youth hostel wouldn't be enough to …

Definitely not a Christie best

Something strange is happening at the boarding house run by Miss Lemon’s sister, Poirot decides to find the answers.

Unsatisfying mystery with unnecessary twists, and almost no Poirot, and can probably win the award for most tenuously titled Christie novel. It’s.… not good, rapidly deteriorating into an inane, and tedious mess.

Holly Black: The Wicked King (2020, Little, Brown Books for Young Readers)

The intrigue intensifies

Jude continues her machinations to ensure the future of Faerie.

I enjoyed this less than the first book in the series. I suppose there was more political intrigue, but it all felt a little tedious. The “romance” fizzled completely for me. I suppose it’s to be seen as a slow burn, but they should both cut their losses and move on, seriously. Betrayal, turn-around, comeuppances, it’s all in here, but I’m just not invested enough to actually care very much. Only one book left, so will finish the series.

Percival Everett: The Trees (Paperback, 2021, Graywolf Press)

Percival Everett’s The Trees is a page-turner that opens with a series of brutal murders …

Gruesome, and darkly amusing

A pair of MBI detectives are sent to Money, Mississippi, to investigate a series of brutal murders, where each crime scene also appears to have an unexpected second body.

I feel somewhat ambivalent about this novel. It’s well-written, and interesting, but ultimately felt a bit unresolved. I’m sure I missed certain things that had I been more steeped in US culture I’d understand differently or better. Everett has a lot of fun with the character names, and it was a treat every time someone new entered the chat.

It’s a gruesome novel, and unfolds differently than first expected. I went in cold, then quickly realised The Trees is much more layered than a straight crime novel. While I didn’t dislike it, and will read more Everett, I suspect I started on a high point by reading James first.

Holly Black: The Cruel Prince (2018, Little, Brown Books for Young Readers)

Jude, seventeen and mortal, gets tangled in palace intrigues while trying to win a place …

Fine Fae Fare

Jude, in her need to safely navigate the treacherous world of Faerie, finds herself catching a tiger by the tail.

I’m not the target audience for this, and that’s fine. The writing is fine, as is the world-building, and the characters. They are on par with what I’d expect from this genre, and it’s fine. A bit tropey at times, but, again, that’s to be expected. I'd have liked more political intrigue, and perhaps more layers to both story and characters, but that's not the point of this book. Still, I’ll probably read the rest of the series just to have done it.

Sonia Purnell: Kingmaker (2024, Penguin Publishing Group)

Interesting bio of a somewhat opaque woman

Tracing the life of a English Baron’s daughter, who, on her way to becoming US ambassador to France, was Winston Churchill’s beloved daughter-in-law.

I knew nothing about Pamela Harrison whatsoever when I started reading this, and I think I’d have both enjoyed and benefitted more from this biography had I been aware of her beforehand. She lived an interesting life, but I lacked context for some of the assertions about Pamela. Being considered one of history’s greatest courtesans is compelling, but the actual text didn’t explain and explore why she was called that to a degree that I found explicatory.

I enjoyed the first half of the book most. Pamela’s childhood and young adulthood was really interesting, whereas the remainder of the book felt a bit overstuffed and just didn’t capture my attention. Probably not a book to read without the proper attention to devote to it. However, …

reviewed Radiant Star by Ann Leckie (Imperial Radch)

Ann Leckie: Radiant Star (Hardcover, Orbit)

Ann Leckie returns to the world of the Imperial Radch in this standalone.

The …

Enjoyable return to the Raach Empire

They want sainthood, he wants freedom and belonging, sie wants protection and safety for a loved one, while she simply wants everything to stop going horribly wrong.

A delightful return to the Imperial Raadch universe in which Leckie shows us a small corner of the Raadch Empire during events previously detailed in the original trilogy.

Lots of politicking and Raachai incomprehension in the face of local customs. Plenty of genders, accompanied this time by a variety of religious practices. I took my time with this to savour it, and my only quibble (this is me problem) is that, unusually for a Leckie work, I failed to find a character to glom on to and adore unabashedly.

Katherine Addison: The Orb of Cairado (EBook, 2025, Subterranean Press)

Set in the world of Hugo, Nebula, and World Fantasy Award nominee The Goblin Emperor, …

Need to reread

A disgraced historian who makes a living creating fake provenances discovers an intriguing puzzle.

The Orb of Cairado features a new protagonist, Ulcetha Zhorvena, a disgraced historian, and seems to be set around the time of The Goblin Emperor. A nice story, though short, and definitely in the same vein as the Thara Celehar books. For some reason I didn’t find it as engaging as the books featuring Celehar. I’ll be rereading it because I suspect my lack of engagement had little to do with the book itself.

Tracy Borman: The House of Boleyn (EBook, Atlantic Monthly Press)

Acclaimed Tudor historian Tracy Borman weaves the dramatic history of the Boleyn family into a …

I prefer Borman's nonfiction

The rise and fall of the Boleyn family’s fortunes, from their pinnacle achievement to the misery of their worst failure.

While I quite enjoyed Borman’s Cromwell biography, I didn’t care much for this novel following the house of Boleyn. The writing was fine, but I found the story messy and a little disjointed, skipping ahead in capricious ways. Had I not been relatively well-versed in the history of happenings at the Tudor court, I’m not sure that I’d have followed the timeline very well.

I also found a few of the characters' personalities too changeable, with no explanation given other than it suited the moment. The interwoven perspectives of the various servants and attendants felt extraneous, and crowbarred in, bogging down rather than enhancing the narrative. The author’s note explains her reasoning, and I see her point, but I just didn’t enjoy the result very much.

Scott Lynch: Locke Lamora and the Bottled Serpent (EBook, 2026, Conversation Tree Press)

The novels in the acclaimed Gentleman Bastards series trace the exploits of an elite band …

A brief return to Camorr

A young Locke is sent off with strict instructions from Father Chains, and he tries oh, so hard, to follow them.

Novella taking us back to Camorr for a summer of storms, wherein our hero needs to behave himself. I’d forgotten how much I enjoy the world Lynch has built for the Gentleman Bastards series, so this was a lovely, albeit brief, return. I prefer Lynch’s novels, finding the format better suited to his writing. He just doesn’t have the space to do that thing he does so well in such a small space. I’ll not turn down any new story featuring Locke Lamora though!