Reviews and Comments

73pctGeek

73pctGeek@bookwyrm.social

Joined 2 years, 2 months ago

73% geek, the rest is girly bits.

I'm a shy lurker who enjoys friendly interaction but is bad at initiating. I like reading. Find me elsewhere on my blog, or on mastodon.

What my stars mean: ★☆☆☆☆ Hated it ★★☆☆☆ Didn't like it ★★★☆☆ It was OK ★★★★☆ Liked it ★★★★★ Loved it

This link opens in a pop-up window

Tim Curry: Vagabond (2025, Penguin Random House)

Feels genuine, but surface level

Actor, musician, voice actor, sex symbol—Tim Curry reflects on his life and works.

A sprawling, messy memoir which feels very genuine in the way it’s written. At various points I considered whether this would have been improved by a more involved editor, but after thinking about it, I’ve decided its best as is. It feels recalled, as if Curry was speaking to someone and remembering his life, rather than a perfectly linear, arranged set of happenings that sometimes memoirs can read as.

I was disappointed in how shallow what Curry was willing to share was, though. I don’t want salacious details, but I didn’t come away with much of an appreciation for what type of person Curry is. A few unguarded utterances gave a peek into what a less reticent memoir could have offered, and I’d have loved more of that.

Emma Donoghue: Slammerkin (2002, Harcourt)

Exciting, riveting, historical period book about a young seamstress who through a series of misfortunes …

Excellent read, but too much for me right now

Mary Saunders doesn’t want to eke out a life sewing piecework like her mother. She wants more; a scarlet ribbon, to wear silks every day, her own coach. When circumstance intervenes she has no choice but to grasp fate with both hands and attempt to bend it to her will.

A reread. It surprised me to find how much more I enjoyed this the first time I read it, originally giving it 4 stars back in 2014. While I still admire Donoghue’s writing and storytelling skills, I suppose I’m just less able to handle the particular flavour of sadness running throughout “Slammerkin” now. It remains excellent historical fiction, just a little too grimdark even for my tastes these days.

K.J. Parker: Inside Man (2021, Tordotcom Publishing)

An anonymous representative of the Devil, once a high-ranking Duke of Hell and now a …

Illuminates Prosper's Demon

After being designated “fragile”, our hero is content with his lot. That is, until circumstance, and those in charge, force him back to more challenging work.

It felt like the second half to “Prosper’s Demon”, with both novella’s sharing characters, and, uh, certain predicaments. I liked this one more, purely because it appealed more to my personal tastes. I love me a shifty protagonist, and the turtles all the way down aspect was delicious.

reviewed Prosper's Demon by Parker (Prosper's Demon I)

Parker: Prosper's Demon (Paperback, 2020, Tor.com)

In a botched demonic extraction, they say the demon feels it ten times worse than …

Geniuses, and babies, and exorcists, oh my!

What do you get when a Genius wants to raise the perfect Philosopher-King, but there is the tiniest possibility of a small demonic possession going on? An exorcist, that’s what.

A fascinating addition to Parker’s fantasy world’s lore, this novella expands what we learnt about religion in “Sister Svangerd and the Not Quite Dead”. Not only is there a loyal opposition, there are demons. Naturally this requires exorcists. Enter our.… hero? As usual, the somewhat shifty narrator is much too clever, and convoluted plans are made. Enjoyed it. Started the sequel immediately.

Charles Portis: True Grit (2010, The Overlook Press)

Read Lonesome Dove instead

Mattie Ross’ father is dead, and she knows who did it. Now she’s looking for someone with grit to help her avenge his murder.

Didn’t care for this at all. I hoped I was in for another “Lonesome Dove” experience, but absolutely did not get that. The plot was simple and straightforward, lacked compelling characters, had an annoying protagonist, and an ending which felt meaningless. At points where an author like McMurty would break your heart with sparse, compelling language, Portis just.… wastes the opportunity to make the reader feel anything other than tedium. I also found Mattie’s compulsive quirk of putting random words in scare quotes increasingly annoying.

Greer Stothers: Apparently, Sir Cameron Needs to Die

In this hilarious, off-the-wall queer fantasy romance, a reclusive sorcerer is forced to protect a …

A little less fun, but also less predictable than I'd imagined

Sir Cameron is a hot, strapping knight with a body that won’t quit. He is also a coward who needs to stop the Sorcerer at all costs. Well, some costs. Maybe.

I somehow stumbled across a small excerpt of this a year or so ago, and was eagerly anticipating the publication, so I could read it the whole thing. While amusing, and different, the full-length novel didn’t quite live up to my expectations.

I found the story pleasingly unpredictable, and while I liked most of the characterisations, I would have enjoyed a little more depth to them. The romance aspect also suffered from being somewhat shallow, and rushed. I didn’t really enjoy the last third of the book very much, and found the ending quite abrupt and unresolved. Still quite fun.

Alison Bechdel: Spent (EBook, Mariner Books)

A good, but stressful read

Cartoonist “Alison Bechdel” struggles to write her new book, as her wife, Holly, becomes a successful YouTuber, and their pygmy goat sanctuary gets a new addition. Envy, money worries, insecurities, feelings of inadequacy all rear their ugly heads in both Alison and her friend group, against a backdrop of a world spiralling ever downwards.

I found the bulk of this hard to properly enjoy. It seemed to keep the story, or me, at a distance, everything seeming at a slight remove. At the same time, I also found it incredibly stressful reading, so Bechdel certainly succeeded in conveying Alison’s mounting unease. The last couple of chapters helped ease the pressure, but I found the ending itself a little too easy and pat. There are some lovely visual gags (the goats, the cats, etc.), and I enjoyed the author’s subtle acknowledgements of age coming for us all. A good read, …

Django Wexler (duplicate): Everybody Wants to Rule the World Except Me (Paperback, 2025, Orbit)

Dark Lord Davi rules the kingdom, but she must now break the time loop that …

Not quite as fun as the first

Davi, now poised to fix things, is quickly disabused of the notion that she can predict how the time loop will play out. It almost feels like something, or someone, is countering her every move.

The conclusion to the story which began with “How to Become the Dark Lord and Die Trying”. Davi attempts personal growth, horde control, peace negotiations, and enjoying a long-term relationship, but a few “surprises” crop up and throw spanners in the works. All in all it was fine, but I didn’t find it as engaging as its predecessor, and didn’t particularly care for the denouement.

Django Wexler (duplicate): How to Become the Dark Lord and Die Trying (2024, Orbit)

Groundhog Day meets Deadpool in Django Wexler’s raunchy, hilarious, blood-splattered fantasy tale about a young …

Fun, and at times funny, Fantasy Rampage (though there is some romping too)

Davi is sick of trying to save the Kingdom, only to fail ad nauseam. So, this time, she’s going to try something different.

A fast, fun fantasy take on isekai stories. Davi is for the most part amusing, but humour is personal, so while I snickered at a good third of her asides, others won’t. Though there are a lot of characters, but all are easily differentiated, and it doesn’t become trying to remember what role they’ve played so far. The story is interesting enough that I’ll be reading the sequel. It’s a self-aware novel that plays with breaking the fourth wall, and I think fans of Lit-RPG style books might enjoy it, even without the endless listing of stats and levelling.

K.J. Parker: Sister Svangerd and the Not Quite Dead (EBook)

A little less fun than previous novels

When you need a princess guzzled at the Ecclesiastical Council, of course you send a monk and a nun to do the deed.

I didn’t find this as enjoyable as previous Parker novels. It’s still entertaining, with the usual type of shifty narrator both the author, and I, favour, but for some reason it just wasn’t as much fun.

I’d have liked it more if it had concentrated on the fifteenth ecumenical council, lost books, faking antiquities, and Svangerd bossing Desiderius around. I’m just not particularly interested in the way things escalated. While I’ll almost certainly read the sequel at some point, I won’t be holding my breath in anticipation of its publication.

reviewed Making History by K.J. Parker

K.J. Parker: Making History (Tordotcom)

History isn't truth...it's propaganda.

Academics can be cocky. Atop their perches of authority high …

Typical K.J. Parker Fare

Citizen Gyges has a chat with his city’s foremost scholars. He has a small request. A tiny one, really.

A quintessentially K. J. Parker novella. Wanting a far too clever for his own good narrator, who is a bit shifty but deep-down basically decent? Check. In need of a complicated scheme involving many moving parts? Parker has got your back.

If you generally enjoy Parker’s books, you’ll like this. I was vaguely disappointed by the denouement, but all in all, found it a delight.

Andy Weir: Project Hail Mary (Hardcover, 2021, Ballantine Books)

Ryland Grace is the sole survivor on a desperate, last-chance mission--and if he fails, humanity …

Not a Weir fan

Waking up, attached to strange medical equipment, he realises that he doesn’t know where he is, why he’s there, or who he even is.

The concept is fine, interesting even, but I do not enjoy Weir’s writing style. In fact, I’d forgotten just how much I dislike it in the decade since I read “The Martian”.

I find Weir tediously didactic, he over-explains everything, and so many plot points are so blatantly telegraphed, it makes a mockery of his supposedly intelligent characters. Speaking of which, I really don’t like Weir’s characters, particularly the protagonist.

Ryland Grace is a cardboard cut-out who cracks unfunny “jokes”, and tiresomely describes his every move. Grace’s character is just flat, despite him crying constantly (that’s how we know he is sad), or him being the coolest teacher ever.

Weir is not for me, I shall stop reading Weir.

William Alexander: Sunward (Paperback, Simon & Schuster Books For Young Readers)

Captain Tova Lir chose a life as a courier rather than get involved in her …

A little too cute

Tova Lir — captain, courier, mentor — has a few mysteries to solve, and she needs to figure out the answers before an assassin can strike.

I found this very light and frothy, and with a much too cutesy vibe for my tastes. It also has no misdirections or explorations of any kind, it’s a simple story told in a straightforward manner. This is not a bad thing, but I like curlicues, details, miscellanea, and complex characters in my fiction. Not bad, but not for me.

Cameron Reed: Fortunate Fall (2024, Doherty Associates, LLC, Tom)

Not quite what I'd hoped for

Maya is a “camera” who broadcasts, not only what she sees, but also what she feels, to billions worldwide. And she just found something worth sharing.

After really enjoying Reed’s short story The Girl That My Mother Is Leaving Me For, I was looking forward to reading this novel, originally published in the 90s. The edition I read included a laudatory foreword by Jo Walton, an author whose opinion I respect, and in retrospect probably raised my expectations a little too high.

Though full of fascinating ideas, and doesn’t read like an old-fashioned relic, it isn’t really my type of sci-fi. Still an interesting book, and Reed wrote some shockingly prescient things. Sadly, not the good kind.

Also, I either prefer Reed’s shorter fiction, or perhaps her newer work. For me, it just didn’t rise to the level of The Girl That My Mother Is Leaving …

Caroline Fraser: Murderland (Hardcover, 2025, Penguin Press, an imprint of Penguin Random House)

Interesting theory about PNW serial killers

Why did a hotspot of horrific, and oddly specific crimes spill across part of the US, during certain decades?

Though Murderland: Crime and Bloodlust in the Time of Serial Killers is well-written and interesting, I’m not sure I’d have made it through the chapters where Fraser lays out the crimes against humanity and nature wrought by industry. While informative, had I been unaware of the lead theory, I would have found it strangely off-topic, and possibly moved on to a different book. I’m still not sure there wasn’t more going on than just poison warping a generation of men, but I certainly don’t know enough to opine.

This book really does read like a True Crime novel, but though the author deftly manages to keep tension constantly mounting throughout, there is no final revelation to release it. And while the catalogue of horrors inflicted throughout the decades is …