User Profile

mirabilos Locked account

mirabilos@outside.ofa.dog

Joined 11 months, 2 weeks ago

DE/EN*; lots of fanfiction, some books and sheet music.

Experimenting with Bookwyrm, to get away from Goodreads and a manually kept text file with things I read.

I mostly keep to the Goodreads rating scale (2 = it was okay, 3 = I liked it, 4 = I really liked it, 5 = top), where I also hand out a 2/3 for a 1/2 when my reason to dislike is more personal than caused by the book. Bad spelling tends to get a downgrade.

*) and bits of Latin, NL, ES, …

This link opens in a pop-up window

Harry Potter a tajemná komnata (Hardcover, Czech language, 2002, Albatros) 4 stars

Harry Potter #2

Throughout the summer holidays after his first year at Hogwarts School of …

Review of 'Harry Potter a tajemná komnata' on 'Goodreads'

1 star

The second book in this series is still written in present tense. It gets slightly worse though, as sentences dealing with the relative past are formed incorrectly.

The author’s A/Ns get worse, too.

Harry has some successes and otherwise keeps being his oblivious self.

And then, in the midst of a chapter, without this being recognisable, the author explodes the fourth wall, and the fifth to go with it, and switches to their PoV and basically deals with the rest of the year (which is just most of it) in a short bullet-point list and ends it. Just like that.

This is utterly insulting.

The only saving grace might be that the author hates Year 2 and might recover a bit for Year 3… might. But nothing of that is published yet.

Woah, going from five stars to one in just 10½ rather short chapters. (Even less, considering most …

Alice in Wonderland (Paperback, 2001, Dover Publications) 3 stars

Alice's Adventures in Wonderland (commonly Alice in Wonderland) is an 1865 English children's novel by …

Review of 'Alice in Wonderland' on 'Goodreads'

3 stars

2½ stars, rounding up for story length (and even then, I’m generous)

At times hard to follow. Way too much romance. Tons of OCs, and a rather OOC Harry. Family Magic as a panacea, inconsistent enemies and inconsequent dealing with traitors in various kinds. I never understood where Bill stands in all this, till the ending (which wasn’t all that satisfying either), and other loose threads exist.