Ben Waber reviewed The Chinese and the Iron Road by Gordon H. Chang
An Insightful, Accessible, Academic Volume of Essays
5 stars
This compilation of different essays focused on various aspects of the Chinese role in building the transcontinental railroad is a fascinating, eclectic mix of historical detective work, economic history, anthropology, and archeology. This work is all the more important because, as is continually emphasized here, there is essentially no written record of this extremely important group of workers. The interdisciplinary nature of the different contributions, made necessary by this data gap, is nicely organized and contextualized by the editors, making this feel much more like a coherent book than similar academic collections. Standouts for me were the chapter on remittances by Yuan Ding and Roland Hsu, the chapter on encounters between Chinese railroad workers and Native Americans by Hsinya Huang, and the chapter on these workers in photography by Denise Khor. The last chapter tried a bit too hard to whitewash Leland Stanford's extremely racist and exploitative stance towards Chinese …
This compilation of different essays focused on various aspects of the Chinese role in building the transcontinental railroad is a fascinating, eclectic mix of historical detective work, economic history, anthropology, and archeology. This work is all the more important because, as is continually emphasized here, there is essentially no written record of this extremely important group of workers. The interdisciplinary nature of the different contributions, made necessary by this data gap, is nicely organized and contextualized by the editors, making this feel much more like a coherent book than similar academic collections. Standouts for me were the chapter on remittances by Yuan Ding and Roland Hsu, the chapter on encounters between Chinese railroad workers and Native Americans by Hsinya Huang, and the chapter on these workers in photography by Denise Khor. The last chapter tried a bit too hard to whitewash Leland Stanford's extremely racist and exploitative stance towards Chinese people (call me old fashioned but the fact that he didn't abuse his personal Chinese servants means essentially nothing against the vast harms, including death, he caused to tens of thousands of Chinese people). That aside, this is an excellent, insightful book on an important part of American, Chinese, and international labor history. Highly recommend