Ben Waber reviewed A Perfect Mess by David F. Labaree
A Sociological View of US Higher Education
4 stars
This is a thorough sociological investigation of US higher education, for better and for worse. On the positive side, Labaree posits a convincing theory of the causes and results of the hierarchical nature of that system, including financial requirements, market structure, and surrounding institutions. It is notably, however, lacking in any quantitative backing for sweeping statements until reaching the 21st century. This makes it hard to take many of the claims Labaree makes at face value, especially given that he completely ignores the extremely illiberal nature of the US throughout history, most egregiously segregation in schools. If you're interested in the sector, however, it's worth a skeptical read
This is a thorough sociological investigation of US higher education, for better and for worse. On the positive side, Labaree posits a convincing theory of the causes and results of the hierarchical nature of that system, including financial requirements, market structure, and surrounding institutions. It is notably, however, lacking in any quantitative backing for sweeping statements until reaching the 21st century. This makes it hard to take many of the claims Labaree makes at face value, especially given that he completely ignores the extremely illiberal nature of the US throughout history, most egregiously segregation in schools. If you're interested in the sector, however, it's worth a skeptical read