Zachary J. Adam reviewed The Martian by Andy Weir
Very Solid Science
4 stars
Mark Watney's problem-solving thought process is sufficiently like software engineering that I'd not be surprised to learn Weir had done some in the past. The story is compelling and the setbacks believable. Mark is not an over-powered superman surviving in an impossible position but a solutions-minded scientist doing his best with what he has available. The supporting cast of earthbound characters is lovable in their own way.
If I was to take a point off anything it's that I find all the characters save mark to be a bit flat, but the perspectives and framing used to deliver the narrative are a bit like having a hand behind your back in that regard. This was a really good "first" outing for Weir and it's not surprising based on this that his other work is also quite good.
Mark Watney's problem-solving thought process is sufficiently like software engineering that I'd not be surprised to learn Weir had done some in the past. The story is compelling and the setbacks believable. Mark is not an over-powered superman surviving in an impossible position but a solutions-minded scientist doing his best with what he has available. The supporting cast of earthbound characters is lovable in their own way.
If I was to take a point off anything it's that I find all the characters save mark to be a bit flat, but the perspectives and framing used to deliver the narrative are a bit like having a hand behind your back in that regard. This was a really good "first" outing for Weir and it's not surprising based on this that his other work is also quite good.